| Year | Race Name | Course | Dist. | Winner | Sire | Dam |
| 2013 | Garden City Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Alterite (FR) | Literato (FR) | Ana Luna (GB) |
| 2012 | Garden City Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Samitar (GB) | Rock of Gibraltar (IRE) | Aileen's Gift (IRE) |
| 2011 | Garden City Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Winter Memories (USA) | El Prado (IRE) | Memories of Silver (USA) |
| 2010 | Garden City Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Check the Label (USA) | Stormin Fever (USA) | Don't Trick Her (USA) |
| 2009 | Garden City Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Miss World (USA) | Bernstein (USA) | Moonstar (USA) |
| 2008 | Garden City Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Backseat Rhythm (USA) | El Corredor (USA) | Kiss a Miss (USA) |
| 2007 | Garden City Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Alexander Tango (IRE) | Danehill Dancer (IRE) | House in Wood (FR) |
| 2006 | Garden City Breeders' Cup Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Magnificent Song (USA) | Unbridled's Song (USA) | Song to Remember (USA) |
| 2005 | Garden City Breeders' Cup Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Luas Line (IRE) | Danehill (USA) | Streetcar (IRE) |
| 2004 | Garden City Breeders' Cup Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Lucifer's Stone (USA) | Horse Chestnut (SAF) | Ladue (USA) |
| 2003 | Garden City Breeders' Cup Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Indy Five Hundled (USA) | A.P. Indy (USA) | Lyphard's Delta (USA) |
| 2002 | Garden City Breeders' Cup Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Wonder Again (USA) | Silver Hawk (USA) | Ameriflora (USA) |
| 2001 | Garden City Breeders' Cup Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Voodoo Dancer (USA) | Kingmambo (USA) | Zuri (USA) |
| 2000 | Garden City Breeders' Cup Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Gaviola (USA) | Cozzene (USA) | Forest Key (USA) |
| 1999 | Garden City Breeders' Cup Stakes | Belmont Park | T 9f | Perfect Sting (USA) | Red Ransom (USA) | Valid Victress (USA) |
