Eat Lanka Look Lanka index Mail



Speak Sinhala / Sinhala Q and A

Tamil and Japanese

Q16 There was a TV program about Tamil language and Japanese.On the program they say that tamil culture and language can be compared with ancient Japan and Japanese language.
Dolmens, deer skin musical instrument are the same in both India and Japan and a curving lines on Yayoi era type earthenwares are also excavated in India. With these archaelogical evidences they insisted that there are some Tamil words in Japan. How do you think it?

Probably it was the TV program of " wonder world discovery " ? I watched that program too.
At the morment , my Sinhalese friend called up me, and shouted " Watch TBS now ! " and cut it off . It was the saturday night 2001 / 06/ 10.
I put on TV and watched that program.

@The contents of the program was about that of Professor Susumu Ono's " Ponga Ponga " theory.
There was typical burial ruin in Tamil speaking area 2000 years ago. In Japan, there is the same burial culture ( using earthwear pots for coffins ) in Kane-no-kuma in Fukuoka. And dolmens of India of 2500 years ago have the same form as the dolmen of Kubo-Izumi-Maruyama in Saga, etc.
On some words , they insist that " flag " is " hata " in Japanese and it is named "patam " in Tamil. Also " talking " is " hanasu " in Japanese , "pannu " in Tamil language. and so on You can get more knowledges about these corresponding words between tamil and Japanese when you read P" Ono's work..
@
Japanese culture have those origin in tamili culture --- this is the theory of P" Ono ,
The narration of the program said that words of Tamil had entered into Japanese during Yayoi period. I remember uncertainly that once he used to said Tamil language itself was same as Japanese.

Ruins speak no words. There are no evidence to define what they had spoken on those days..
Here we have Mc restaurant in Japan. It was come from US, and Mc culture is popular in Japan.. But it is sure that the Japanese speak Japanese even if they went to there and eat American Mc hamburgers every day.

If Japanese is the same as Tamil language, every the Japanese may be speak Tamil easily..But Tamil language is far from the Japanese tongue on many points.
Tamil Pronunciation , grammer composition , both of them are very diffarent from Japanese language. As one of linguistics said once like this --- Tamil is resemble to Korean language, and I think so, too..

By the way, that program mentioned about "funeral ceremonies" only. Why so gloomy? If it were Sinhala and Japanese language , they have same words on "marriage" and "festival" .These relationships are not gloomy.

Words of relatives
Japanese - Sinhala language words correspondence table
God and others Japanese - Sinhala language words correspondence table